CASE STUDY
$55K IRS Tax Debt
➜ Reduced to $10K Through Innocent Spouse Appeal
Customer: Mary D., Schenectady, NY
Timeframe: October 2024 – August 2026
Situation
Following her husband’s death, Mary D. began receiving IRS collection notices, including a CP91, Notice of Intent to Levy, for approximately $55,000 in tax liabilities dating back to 2015, arising almost entirely from her late husband’s self-employment income.
Mary had not been involved in preparing their joint tax returns, raising questions about her knowledge of and involvement in the filing process.
Seeking a resolution, Mary hired a tax attorney and paid approximately $6,000. The attorney submitted an Offer in Compromise (OIC), which the IRS rejected because Mary had substantial assets, including her home.
Told that a full-pay installment agreement was her only remaining option, Mary turned to Tax Fighters Inc. for a second opinion.
Challenge
In addition to the rejected OIC, Mary’s case presented two further significant challenges.
First, establishing her responsibility for the debt. The liabilities arose primarily from her husband’s income, yet Mary was held responsible because they had filed joint returns. She had not prepared the returns, and her signature had been forged on two of them.
Second, overcoming the IRS’s initial denial of Innocent Spouse relief. After Tax Fighters Inc. submitted the request, the IRS issued a standard denial stating that Mary did not qualify, without adequately addressing several underlying circumstances.
Approach 1: Finding the Right Resolution
- Rather than accepting a full-pay installment agreement, Tax Fighters Inc. examined why Mary owed the taxes in the first place.
- Reviewed the liabilities, income sources, and Mary’s involvement in preparing and filing the returns, identifying two forged signatures.
- Determined that Innocent Spouse relief, rather than another OIC, was the appropriate strategy.
- Reviewed the Collection Statute Expiration Dates (CSEDs) and identified that the collection periods for 2015 and 2016 were approaching expiration.
- Allowed those periods to run their course and focused the Innocent Spouse request on 2017 through 2020.
- Prepared and submitted the request covering those four years.
Approach 2: Appealing the IRS Denial
- Reviewed the denial, identified circumstances the IRS had not adequately considered, and filed a formal appeal.
- Presented Mary’s circumstances directly to an IRS Appeals Officer, including her limited involvement in the filings and the source of the income.
- Negotiated an allocation of each year’s tax liability, including penalties and interest, between Mary and her husband based on their relative earned incomes.
Results
- During the appeals process, Tax Fighters Inc. reached an agreement under which the tax liability for each year, including the associated penalties and interest, was allocated between Mary and her husband based on their relative earned incomes.
- Because the overwhelming majority of the income that created the tax liability belonged to Mary’s husband, the allocation dramatically reduced the amount Mary was responsible for.
- Mary’s IRS liability was reduced from approximately $55,000 to $10,000, saving her approximately $45,000.